110 My Way, Old Forge, NY 13420 (MLS# 206945)

Description

This magnificent year-round log home on First Lake offers 200 feet of pristine sandy frontage and stunning views with McCauley Mountain in the distance. From quiet mornings on the spacious deck to long summer days on the lake, this is a place where memories are made and time slows down. Warm and inviting, the home is filled with Adirondack character, featuring vaulted ceilings, rich wood finishes, and a natural sense of comfort throughout. The primary bedroom is located on the main level, with two additional bedrooms and a full bath upstairs. The walkout lower level adds valuable living space with a bedroom, full bath, and beautiful lake views--ideal for hosting family and guests. Propane Vermont Castings stoves on both the main and lower levels provide warmth and ambiance, while the updated eat-in kitchen offers an easy gathering space after a day outdoors. A well-built dock with steel pilings extends into the clear, sandy shoreline--perfect for swimming, boating, and enjoying the waterfront lifestyle. Set on approximately 1.7 acres in a quiet, private setting, just minutes from the village of Old Forge, this property offers the perfect balance of peaceful lakefront living and convenient access to year-round Adirondack recreation.

Contract Information

Short Term Rental Options: Unknown Current Price: $2,025,000 Original List Price: 2025000 List Price: $2,025,000 Status: Pending Listing Contract Date: 2026-04-16 Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence Listing Agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell Occupant Type: Owner

Location, Tax, and Legal

Tax Annual Amount: 3981 Tax Assessed Value: 1473000 Land Tax Annual Amount: 12905 APA: Hamlet Deed Date: 2010-01-06

General Property Information

Seasonal Property YN: No Main Level Bedrooms: 1 Main Level Bathrooms: 1 Below Grade Unfinished Area: 0 Lot Size Dimensions: 201.2 x393.70 x 201.85 x 389.94 Waterfront Footage: 201 Senior Community YN: No Lease Term: None Horse YN: No Stories Total: 1 Fireplace YN: Yes Bedrooms Total: 4 Bathrooms Total: 3 Bathrooms Full: 3 Above Grade Finished Area: 2538 Building Area Total: 2538 Living Area: 2538 Year Built: 1987 Lot Size Acres: 1.7 Waterfront YN: 1 Water Body Name: First Lake

Status Change Information

Status Change Timestamp: 2026-05-01 Major Change Timestamp: 2026-05-01T16:57:32Z Major Change Type: Status Change Under Contract Date: 2026-04-24

Appliances

Dishwasher: 1 Dryer: 1 Gas Oven: 1 Gas Range: 1 Microwave: 1 Refrigerator: 1 Washer: 1 Water Heater: 1

Architectural Style

Chalet: 1 Log: 1

Basement

Finished: 1 Full: 1 Walk-Out Access: 1

Construction Materials

Log: 1

Cooling

Ceiling Fan(s): 1

Deed Details

Instrument: deed Volume: 1343

Documents Available

Property Condition: 1 Survey: 1

Electric

200+ Amp Service: 1

Exemptions

No Exemptions: 1

Exterior Features

Dock: 1

Fencing

None: 1

Financial Details

School Taxes: 3981 School Taxes Description: Actual

Fireplace Features

Family Room: 1 Living Room: 1 Propane: 1 Fireplaces Total: 2

Flooring

Carpet: 1 Wood: 1

Foundation Details

Block: 1

Frontage Type

Lakefront: 1 Waterfront: 1

Heating

Tank Location: Above Ground Baseboard: 1 Electric: 1 Propane Stove: 1 Wall Furnace: 1

Interior Features

Ceiling Fan(s): 1 Eat-in Kitchen: 1 High Ceilings: 1 High Speed Internet: 1 His and Hers Closets: 1 Kitchen Island: 1 Natural Woodwork: 1 Stone Counters: 1

Laundry Features

Lower Level: 1

Levels

One and One Half: 1

Listing Terms

Cash: 1 Conventional: 1

Lot Features

Views: 1 Waterfront: 1 Wooded: 1

Other Structures

Shed(s): 1

Parking Features

Asphalt: 1 Driveway: 1

Patio And Porch Features

Front Porch: 1 Side Porch: 1

Pets Allowed

Yes: 1

Pool Features

None: 1

Property Condition

Updated/Remodeled: 1

Road Frontage Type

Public: 1

Road Surface Type

Gravel: 1 Paved: 1

Roof

Asphalt: 1 Composition: 1

Sewer

Septic Tank: 1

Spa Features

None: 1

Structure Type

Dock: 1 House: 1

Utilities

Electricity Connected: 1 Internet Connected: 1 Water Connected: 1 Propane: 1

View

Beach: 1 Lake: 1 Trees/Woods: 1

Water Source

Well Drilled: 1

Waterfront Features

Beach Front: 1 Lake: 1 Waterfront: 1

Window Features

Double Pane Windows: 1 Wood Frames: 1

Showing Requirements

Appointment Only: 1 Call Listing Agent: 1 Lockbox: 1 No Sign: 1 Text Listing Agent: 1

Location Tax and Legal

Street Number: 110 Street Name: My Street Suffix: Way County: Herkimer State: NY Postal Code: 13420 MLS Area Major: Old Forge, Inlet, Eagle Bay, Big Moose School District: Town of Webb UFSD Parcel Number: 042.32-1-7.2 Zoning: Residential Directions: From the village of Old Forge, follow Route 28 to Hollywood Road, turn left on Morrow Point Road, and turn right on May Way at the end of the road. Home is on the right, no signage.

Property Features

Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Gas Oven; Gas Range; Microwave; Refrigerator; Washer; Water Heater Architectural Style: Chalet; Log Basement: Finished; Full; Walk-Out Access Construction Materials: Log Cooling: Ceiling Fan(s) Documents Available: Property Condition; Survey Electric: 200+ Amp Service Exemptions: No Exemptions Exterior Features: Dock Fencing: None Fireplace Features: Family Room; Living Room; Propane Flooring: Carpet; Wood Foundation Details: Block Frontage Type: Lakefront; Waterfront Heating: Baseboard; Electric; Propane Stove; Wall Furnace Interior Features: Ceiling Fan(s); Eat-in Kitchen; High Ceilings; High Speed Internet; His and Hers Closets; Kitchen Island; Natural Woodwork; Stone Counters Laundry Features: Lower Level Levels: One and One Half Listing Terms: Cash; Conventional Lot Features: Views; Waterfront; Wooded Other Structures: Shed(s) Parking Features: Asphalt; Driveway Patio And Porch Features: Front Porch; Side Porch Pets Allowed: Yes Pool Features: None Property Condition: Updated/Remodeled Road Frontage Type: Public Road Surface Type: Gravel; Paved Roof: Asphalt; Composition Sewer: Septic Tank Spa Features: None Structure Type: Dock; House Utilities: Electricity Connected; Internet Connected; Water Connected; Propane View: Beach; Lake; Trees/Woods Water Source: Well Drilled Waterfront Features: Beach Front; Lake; Waterfront Window Features: Double Pane Windows; Wood Frames Showing Requirements: Appointment Only; Call Listing Agent; Lockbox; No Sign; Text Listing Agent